I love India as my nation (please don't confuse it with the word "state"). Ours is a nation of bewildering diversities in ethnicity religions, languages, philosophies, cultures, regions, social hierarchies, economic conditions etc. In fact, every personality is unique in itself.
In spite of all this, there had been & still are, some people who want to "assimilate" these differences through a melting-pot approach and create a "bhartiya/deshaj/deshbhakt" India which is honestly speaking impossible to define without entrapping yourself into the fascistic tendencies of the likes of Mussolini & Hitler. Even for these two, it was easy to carve out an Italian & a German nationalism respectively as these nations are almost linguistically & culturally homogeneous & even if those elements that were heterogeneous elements were suppressed, hidden, assimilated & even cleansed from their national scenario.
But the question that I would like to put in front of you all is that is it possible to create a homogeneous Indian nation? If you believe that it is possible to create a homogeneous nation then the question in my mind is that who will define & decide the "Indian-ness" required to being a loyal citizen of India? Will it be RSS who should be conferred with the task of measuring the loyalty of Indian citizens or should it be the Congress Party who should be accepted as the final authority of judging someone's secular credentials?
If you share the same opinion like me that all the concepts & efforts of "assimilation" are doomed to fail then the biggest question that we face is to firstly define what is meant by us when we use the term "Indian nationalism" as the western concepts of Nationalism are impossible to apply & replicate in India as our nation is not homogeneous at all & in addition to this is the fact that we are still a faith-based society, this question requires immensely deep understanding of the various aspects of India & utmost patience & care in dealing with the different aspirations, ideologies & visions of Indian people.
The second problem that I see is that of building a national level consensus of making all parties agree to the definition that will be formulated which is indeed a monumental task.
The third problem that I see is to form the working methodology of implementing the agreed common minimum programme for inclusive development.
The fourth problem I feel is to discover/create & bring all those people together who would co-ordinate & form a responsible Legislature, Judiciary, Bureaucracy & Civil Society.
The fifth problem according to me is to make a consensus as to whether for all things mentioned above to become feasible will some minute reforms be enough or will radical reforms be required or even not less than a complete revolution is required to take place for bringing the new system.
In addition to all these problems that I mentioned here, there are many more questions that need to be found answers of. All these questions are coming up because the Indian state has been unable to deliver on the promise of an inclusive, just & progressive nation.
Yet, I am not at all a pessimist and strongly believe that a near Utopian nation is possible if we will be successful in consolidating, uniting & synchronizing all the energies that are working to create a better nation. As this nation is a shared contemporary reality of all the Indians & our honour is undoubtedly related to it, these questions hold paramount importance in present times. It is my deeply rooted belief that together we can & we will make the difference. With hope & faith I submit this to all the readers for comments, suggestions & ruthless scrutiny.